• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Main Navigation
  • Skip to Search

Indiana University Bloomington Indiana University Bloomington IU Bloomington

Open Search Menu
  • Home
  • Undergraduate
    • Why O'Neill
    • Degrees & Majors
    • Minors & Certificates
    • Courses & Advising
    • Academic & Leadership Programs
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
  • Masters
    • Academic & Leadership Programs
    • Why O’Neill?
    • Degrees & Certificates
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
  • Doctoral
    • Why O'Neill?
    • Degrees
    • How to Apply
    • Student Funding
    • On the Job Market
    • Recent Placements
    • Current Students
    • Dissertations
    • Contact
  • Online & Executive
    • Online Programs
    • Executive Education
  • Faculty & Research
    • Faculty Directory
    • Research
    • Speaker Series
    • Journals & Books
  • Career Services
    • Explore Careers & Outcomes
    • For Students
    • For Alumni
    • For Employers
    • Careers Login
    • Contact Us
  • Student Life
    • Life at O’Neill
    • Life in Bloomington
    • For International Students
    • Resilience and Wellbeing Initiative
    • Mentor Collective
    • O’Neill International
    • Leadership Opportunities
    • Student Organizations
    • Virtual Tour
  • About
    • Dean’s Welcome
    • Strategic Goals and Progress
    • About Paul H. O'Neill
    • 50th Anniversary
    • Environment, Climate, and Sustainability
    • Mission, Vision, and Values
    • Rankings
    • School Profile
    • Global and International Partnerships
    • Office of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
    • Bloomington & Indianapolis
    • Careers at O'Neill
    • Administration & Staff Directory
    • Dean’s Council
  • Search
  • Alumni & Giving
  • Contact
  • Events
  • News
  • IUPUI
  • Current Students
  • Home
  • News
  • News Archive
  • 2009
  • What Does the Future Hold for the Auto Industry?

What Does the Future Hold for the Auto Industry?

By: Reprinted courtesy of the Indianapolis Star

Monday, June 22, 2009

If an auto company is to survive and prosper from 2010 to 2020, it must do three things well: offer vehicles that consumers want to buy, make those vehicles at a lower cost than in the past, and make them "greener" than they have ever been before. Even with hard work and creativity, there are no guarantees. A company's fate may be determined by the uncertain future of world oil prices or the future decisions of politicians.

With U.S. car sales slumping from a peak of 16 million per year to fewer than 10 million per year, all of the automakers — including Toyota and Honda — are suffering. Rather than let market forces take their harsh toll, the Bush and Obama administrations chose to subsidize a future for a downsized GM and a Fiat-led Chrysler.

Compounding the deep recession is a new regulatory mandate: The industry must boost mileage from 25 to 36 miles per gallon by 2016 — the largest push for green vehicles in America's history.

A downsized GM needs to focus on building pickup trucks, sport utility vehicles and sedans at lower cost while continuing to expand its profitable Chinese partnerships. The Fiat-Chrysler challenge is more daunting. Fiat specializes in small cars but the U.S. market is already flooded with low-margin small cars from Toyota, Honda and Volkswagen. Chrysler has developed a niche in minivans and trucks, which Fiat would be wise to retain and nurture. Fiat can help Chrysler develop greener engines. Ford is well positioned in the promising market for pickup trucks and fuel-efficient sedans, and is the only sure survivor among the old Big Three.

Contrary to what politicians say, it will not be easy making a profit by offering green vehicles. While fuel prices at the pump are now rising to their summer peak, the global economic recovery is unlikely to push U.S. fuel prices over $3 per gallon for a sustained period of time before 2015. With low fuel prices and politicians unwilling to raise federal and state fuel taxes, most consumers who enter showrooms will continue to favor pickup trucks, SUVs, vans and mid-sized or large sedans. The small-car market, while thriving in most of the world, will not boom in the United States. America's families need larger vehicles, and our highways and cities are designed to accommodate them.

Making larger vehicles more fuel-efficient will be costly: at least $1,000 per vehicle for Ford's "EcoBoost" improvements to the gasoline engine, $1,000 to $5,000 for a clean diesel engine, and $2,500 to $7,500 for a hybrid engine. The added cost for plug-in hybrids may be more than $10,000.

If fuel prices stay below $3 per gallon, none of these innovations will find much enthusiasm in the U.S. marketplace.

It does not make sense for politicians to force automakers to build green vehicles unless government is willing to provide consumers an incentive to purchase them. In the near term, Congress needs to renew the federal income tax credits for consumer purchases of clean diesel and hybrid engines — credits that expire in 2010. Over time, government needs to offer rebates for high-mileage vehicles and impose fees on the guzzlers.

The new "feebate" system should favor greener vehicles in each size class, rather than simply subsidize the lightest — and least safe — cars. A Ford F-150 with an efficient diesel engine should be favored over a thirsty pickup with a gasoline engine. To ensure that "feebates" do not become a tax increase, the total amount of rebates should be set equal to the total amount of fees. If green vehicles are favored on both the supply and demand sides of the market, it will be feasible for auto companies to make a profit while protecting the environment.

by John D. Graham

  • Undergraduate
    • Why O'Neill
      • High-impact Practices
    • Degrees & Majors
      • Bachelor of Science in Public Affairs (BSPA)
      • Bachelor of Science in Environmental Science (BSES)
      • Bachelor of Arts in Environmental and Sustainability Studies (BAESS)
      • Bachelor of Science in Healthcare Management and Policy (BSHMP)
      • Bachelor of Science in Arts Management (BSAM)
    • Minors & Certificates
    • Courses & Advising
      • Advising
        • Resources
        • Advising Staff
      • Courses
        • General Ed and Intro
        • Topics V450
        • Topics V456
    • Academic & Leadership Programs
      • O’Neill Launch
      • Civic Leaders Center
        • Director’s Welcome
      • Rising Leaders Program
      • NextGeneration Leadership Program
      • Indiana Leadership Program
      • Washington Leadership Program
        • Courses & Faculty
        • Estimated Costs
      • Honors Program
        • Student Spotlights
        • O'Neill Expo
      • Required Internship
      • Accelerated Master's Program
      • O'Neill + Maurer JD
    • How to Apply
      • Current IU Bloomington Students
      • High School Students
      • Transfer students
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • O’Neill Scholarships
        • For Current Students
        • For Incoming Students
      • Non-O’Neill Funding Opportunities
    • Contact & Visit
  • Masters
    • Academic & Leadership Programs
    • Why O’Neill?
      • Leadership Seminar Series
      • Capstone
      • Mission and Goals
    • Degrees & Certificates
      • Master of Public Affairs (MPA)
        • Core Curriculum
        • Concentrations
        • Washington, D.C. Accelerator Program
        • Capstone
        • Experiential Requirement
      • Master of Science in Environmental Science (MSES)
        • Core Curriculum
        • Concentrations
        • Capstone
        • Experiential Requirement
      • MPA-MSES Dual Degree
        • Components & Concentrations
      • Master of Environmental Sustainability (MES)
      • Master of Science in Healthcare Management (MSHM)
        • Curriculum
        • Practicum Experience
        • Executive Education
        • Careers
      • Master of International Affairs (MIA)
      • MPA-MIA Dual Degree
      • Master of Arts in Arts Administration (MAAA)
        • Curriculum
        • Experiential Requirements
        • Faculty Profiles & Publications
        • For Jacobs Students
        • For Doctoral Students
      • MAAA-MPA Dual Degree
      • Additional Dual Degrees
      • Certificates
    • How to Apply
    • Cost & Financial Aid
      • Fellowships & Financial Resources
      • Prior Professional Experience Benefits
      • Volunteer Benefits & Programs
        • AmeriCorps
        • Peace Corps
        • Teach for America
      • Military and Veteran Benefits
      • Funding for Current Students
      • Funding for International Students
      • Federal Financial Aid
    • Contact & Visit
      • Subscribe to our Newsletter
      • Virtual Sessions & Webinars
      • Experience Day
      • Schedule a Visit
      • Connect with a Current Student
      • O'Neill Visits You
  • Doctoral
    • Why O'Neill?
    • Degrees
      • Ph.D. in Public Affairs
        • Environmental Policy
        • Public Finance
        • Public Management
        • Public Policy Analysis
      • Ph.D. in Environmental Science
    • How to Apply
    • Student Funding
      • Environmental Science Fellowships
    • On the Job Market
    • Recent Placements
    • Current Students
    • Dissertations
    • Contact
  • Online & Executive
    • Online Programs
      • About
        • Why O’Neill ?
        • Our Mission and Goals
      • Online MPA
        • Degree Requirements and Curriculum
        • O’Neill Online Week
      • Online Graduate Certificates
        • Nonprofit Management
        • Public Management
        • Public & Nonprofit Evaluation
      • How to Apply
        • Tuition & Fees
        • Financial Aid
      • Faculty
      • Student Life
        • Meet Our Students
        • Meet Our Alumni
        • For Professionals
        • For Military Students
        • Helping You Succeed
      • Contact Us
        • Information Sessions
    • Executive Education
  • Faculty & Research
    • Faculty Directory
    • Research
      • Environmental Research and Policy
      • Covid-19
      • Racial Justice
      • Research Areas
      • Faculty Research Publications
      • Laboratories
      • Centers & Initiatives
      • Working Research Groups
    • Speaker Series
    • Journals & Books
  • Career Services
    • Explore Careers & Outcomes
    • For Students
      • Register Your Internships
      • Internship Funds and Scholarships
    • For Alumni
    • For Employers
    • Careers Login
    • Contact Us
  • Student Life
    • Life at O’Neill
    • Life in Bloomington
    • For International Students
    • Resilience and Wellbeing Initiative
    • Mentor Collective
    • O’Neill International
    • Leadership Opportunities
    • Student Organizations
    • Virtual Tour
  • About
    • Dean’s Welcome
    • Strategic Goals and Progress
    • About Paul H. O'Neill
    • 50th Anniversary
    • Environment, Climate, and Sustainability
    • Mission, Vision, and Values
    • Rankings
    • School Profile
    • Global and International Partnerships
      • Vietnam Initiatives
        • Vietnam Young Leaders Award
    • Office of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
      • Activate O'Neill
      • Support & Resources
      • Who We Are
    • Bloomington & Indianapolis
    • Careers at O'Neill
    • Administration & Staff Directory
    • Dean’s Council
  • Alumni & Giving
    • Alumni
      • Get Involved
      • Alumni Events
      • Alumni Stories
      • Alumni Recognition
      • Advisory Groups
        • Distinguished Alumni Council
        • Alumni Board of Directors
    • Giving
      • Areas to Support
      • Ways to Give
      • Our Supporters
    • Alumni Communications
    • Contact Us
  • Contact
  • Events
  • News
  • IUPUI
  • Current Students