Ji Ma, an assistant professor at Paul H. O’Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs, has received the prestigious Wilson C. “Bill” Levis Fundraising Research Grant from the Association of Fundraising Professionals Foundation for Philanthropy.
Ma’s project, “From Black Box to Responsible Practice: Benchmarking AI Tools for Strategic Giving,” uses rigorous behavioral allocation experiments to benchmark AI tools, assessing whether and how AI-generated appeals trigger real giving behaviors compared to traditional human-led approaches.
“Receiving this recognition from AFP is a powerful validation that our research addresses pressing questions facing frontline fundraising professionals, not just theoretical discussions in academia,” Ma said. “It gives me an exciting opportunity to bridge cutting-edge technology with the practical realities of the philanthropic sector.”
As nonprofits rapidly adopt generative artificial intelligence to craft fundraising appeals and engage donors, fundraising research highlights that charitable giving fundamentally relies on activating deep personal motivations, including donor trust, perceived efficacy, and shared values. Generic or transactional AI messaging risks undermining relationships vital to philanthropic success.
The goal of the project is to provide evidence-based benchmarks and practical guidelines to limit the risk of AI adoption for nonprofit fundraisers and philanthropic organizations nationwide, to ensure technological innovation strengthens rather than strains donor connections.
“Financially, the funding supports the behavioral experiments needed to establish human benchmarks against which we can evaluate AI tools and appeals,” Ma said. “What's more important, AFP provides a collaborative platform to share our findings and gather direct feedback from practitioners, ensuring the research remains actionable and useful to the sector.”

